The Board of Peace is frustrated. Six months ago, in July 2026, the Board of Peace signed a 15-point framework with Hamas aimed at disarming the terror group and other armed organizations in Gaza. The framework forms part of US President Donald Trump’s 20-point plan, unveiled in October 2025 and also accepted by Israel.

“This is a major step toward lasting security and peace,” Trump wrote on Truth Social at the time.

But since then, the framework has made little progress. While the Board of Peace is pointing the finger at Hamas, it is also increasingly directing its criticism at Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

“President Trump has said clearly to Hamas that they will disarm either the easy way or the hard way. Our issue is that Prime Minister Netanyahu appears to be picking the ‘no way’ and is content returning to the policies of October 6,” Josh Gruenbaum, a senior adviser to the Board of Peace and a former White House official who worked closely with Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, told The Jerusalem Post.

Gruenbaum’s frustration is not limited to what he sees as Israel’s obstacles to implementing the plan to disarm Hamas - an issue we will return to shortly. He is also angered by a series of what he describes as “fake news” and false claims by Israeli officials in recent weeks, alleging that the Board of Peace is “giving in” to Hamas.

A Palestinian Hamas terrorist stands guard as Palestinians walk on a street during Eid al-Fitr, in Gaza City, March 20, 2026
A Palestinian Hamas terrorist stands guard as Palestinians walk on a street during Eid al-Fitr, in Gaza City, March 20, 2026 (credit: REUTERS/DAWOUD ABU ALKAS)

“The current government is aware, and we have been crystal clear with them, that reconstruction will not commence until there is confirmed demilitarization,” Gruenbaum said.

He was responding to claims that the Board of Peace is already pushing to rebuild the Gaza Strip and construct permanent housing for Palestinians before Hamas has agreed to surrender even a single weapon.

“President Trump and the 20-point plan have been clear on this issue. With that said, there is a major difference between bringing in humanitarian aid to allow people to survive during the winter, which is what we are encouraging COGAT and the current government to support, and building permanent structures,” he said.

Board of Peace denies demanding Israel withdraw before Hamas disarmament

But this is not the only claim being made by senior Israeli officials. Some briefings have suggested that the Board of Peace is demanding an Israeli withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip before Hamas is disarmed. The Board of Peace firmly rejects that claim, insisting that no such demand has ever been made.

The agreement, it stresses, explicitly states that an Israeli withdrawal will take place only after Hamas has been fully disarmed.

In recent weeks, Israel has stepped up targeted killings of senior Hamas figures and terrorists involved in the October 7 massacre. Hardly a day goes by without at least one targeted killing in the Strip.

The Board of Peace describes this approach as a return to the “October 6 mindset” - an attempt to contain the situation rather than explore an alternative that could genuinely lead to Hamas’s disarmament.

The frustration with Israel is even greater, officials say, because for months Netanyahu and his government have refused to take two relatively straightforward steps that constitute the first phase of the disarmament framework.

“If the Israeli public would like to know why the demilitarization process of Hamas has not begun yet, they should ask their own government,” Gruenbaum told the Post.

“As prescribed in Trump’s plan, the International Stabilization Force and the local police force must be in place to carry out the demilitarization effort. For that to happen, Israel must sign the SOFA agreement so that the multinational force can begin operating. The local Palestinian force, which has already cleared Israeli background checks, must also be allowed to leave for training.

“This is the foundation of the disarmament plan, and without it, Hamas’s verbal agreement will remain just words.”

According to the Board of Peace, neither of these steps has yet been taken.

“We have not been given a good reason by the prime minister as to why the government is refusing to approve these steps, which are obligations it previously committed itself to in its agreement with President Trump,” Gruenbaum said.

BoP says Israel refusing to test framework even without security compromise

It is important to stress that the Board of Peace does not regard Hamas as a “righteous” actor. But its officials say they cannot understand why Israel is refusing to test a framework that, at this stage, does not require it to compromise on its security.

As long as Gaza remains undemilitarized, there will be no reconstruction and no Israeli withdrawal. Trump has already made clear that if Hamas does not voluntarily surrender its weapons, “it will do so the hard way.”

Even former Strategic Affairs Minister Ron Dermer, a close confidant of Netanyahu, said in a November 2026 interview with the School of War podcast that the diplomatic framework should be given a chance to disarm Hamas “the easy way” before another military operation is considered.

“If Israel does not want the Board of Peace to operate, it should simply tell President Trump, and we will walk away and make room for other entities, like the UN, UNRWA, and the Palestinian Authority, to step in and do the job,” Gruenbaum said.

The patience of Board of Peace officials - and, it appears, senior White House figures - is rapidly running out.